Sam Talbot, the heartthrob finalist from Top Chef's second season, is officially off the market.
The chef and his fiancée, Paola Guerrero, got married in a secret wedding ceremony at City Hall in New York City on Nov. 17, a source close to Talbot confirms to PEOPLE.
"It was just the two of them, looking low-key but gorgeous," says the source. "They are madly in love, and he is the happiest man alive to call her his wife."
Talbot and Guerrero, a model and T-shirt designer from Colombia, met on his 30th birthday in Brazil last December.
"She's amazing. She's stunning," Talbot told PEOPLE last year when he announced their engagement.